Representation Review 2024- Frequently asked questions  

 

What is the Final Proposal?

  • Maintain eight (8) councillors and the Mayor 

  • Mixed system (combination model) comprising:

    • the Mayor elected 'at large' (district wide)

    • two (2) councillors elected ‘at large’ (district-wide) 

    • Kawerau Māori Ward: represented by three (3) Māori ward councillors, with the ward boundaries aligning with the district’s boundaries (see map)

    • Kawerau General Ward: represented by three (3) general ward councillors, with the ward boundaries aligning with the district's boundaries (see map)   

  • No community board 

Why is the Final Proposal the same as the Initial Proposal?

 What is your view on retaining eight (8) councillors and the mayor to represent the Kawerau District?

  • 76.92% (80) submitters support maintaining eight councillors 
    • 41.35% (43) submitters strongly agree to maintaining eight councillors 
    • 35.58% (37) submitters agree to maintaining eight councillors 
  • 14.42% (15) submitters oppose to maintaining eight councillors 
    • 8.65% (9) submitters strongly disagree with maintaining eight councillors 
    • 5.77% (6) submitters disagree with maintaining eight councillors 
  • 8.65% (9) submitters did not have a view 

OR what is your preferred number of councillors?

  • 0.96% (1) submitter wants 2 councillors 
  • 0.96% (1) submitter wants 5 councillors
  • 12.5% (13) submitters want 6 councillors 
  • 1.92% (2) submitters want 7 councillors 
  • 74.04% (77) submitters want 8 councillors 
  • 0% of submitters want 9 councillors 
  • 1.92% (2) submitters want 10 councillors
  • 7.69% (8) submitters did not have a view 
  • What does making an appeal mean?

 What is your view on the initial proposal - the mixed system

  • 57.69% (60) submitters support the initial proposal 
    • 30.77% (32) submitters strongly agree with the initial proposal
    • 26.92% (28) submitters agree with the initial proposal 
  • 33.65% (35) submitters oppose the initial proposal 
    • 23.08% (24) submitters strongly disagree with the initial proposal 
    • 10.58% (11) submitters disagree with the initial proposal 
  • 8.65% (9) submitters did not have a view

Who can make an appeal?

Any person or organisation that has made a submission on the Representation Review 2024 –Initial Proposal may lodge a written appeal that: 
a) must identify the matters to which the appeal relates; and 
b) may raise only those matters that were raised in the original submission. 

What does making an appeal mean?

If Council receives submissions, it considers these and may change its proposal as a result. If a person or organisation who made a submission is not satisfied with the council's amended final proposal, they can appeal against it. 

If there are no appeals or objections, the proposal becomes the basis of election at the next triennial election and the council must give public notice accordingly.

If Council receives any appeal or objection, we must refer our proposal to the Local Government Commission for determination along with the appeals and objections received.

Can I have my say on whether I want Māori wards?

The decision to implement Māori wards was made in November 2023, and was reaffirmed on 14 August 2024. The Representation Review is taking place to work out how Council can be structured with the introduction of Māori ward councillors.  

As per the new Act, voters can have your say, at the 2025 election, when a poll will be run with the elections asking whether people wish to maintain Māori wards or not.  

What can I make an appeal on?

Any person or organisation that has made a submission on the Representation Review 2024 –Initial Proposal may lodge a written appeal that: 
a) must identify the matters to which the appeal relates; and 
b) may raise only those matters that were raised in the original submission. 

Has Council made a decision whether they will rescind or reaffirm Māori wards yet?

Yes, in an Ordinary Council Meeting held on Wednesday, 14 August, Council reaffirmed the decision to introduce Māori wards which was made on 22 November 2023. 

Councillors agreed unanimously to reaffirm their decision for Māori Wards to honour their commitment to this community, and to proceed with the consultation underway with the representation review.  

The decision was required after the government’s new Local Government (Electoral Legislation and Māori Wards and Māori Constituencies) Amendment Act 2024 became law last month.  

This Act restores the provisions for a poll or referendum on Māori Wards and will mean that as part of the 2025 election, Council will hold a binding poll (referendum) asking if Māori wards should stay in place for the next two elections (2028 and 2031) or not.  

What is the difference between my formal submission and the early engagement feedback I gave at the start of the year for the Representation Review? 

The early engagement feedback gave us an understanding of what the community wanted and how they would feel best represented with the introduction of Māori ward(s). The early engagment helped us put together the initial proposal that effectively and fairly meets the needs of the community. 

The formal submission period is asking if you support the initial proposal. These submissions will be taken into account by Council and the Local Government Commission (if applicable). This process also gives people the opportunity to present their views (submission) to the Mayor and elected members.

The outcome of this formal submission process that closes on 26 August 2024 and hearing to be held on Wednesday 11  September - will inform the final proposal that will need to be adopted by Council on 25 September 2024.  

What are you proposing?

Council has considered all the feedback from the early engagement and are proposing:  

  • Mixed system (combination model) which was supported by 60% of respondents in the early engagement   

comprising: the Mayor; Two councillors elected ‘at large’ district-wide; Three Councillors representing the Kawerau Māori Ward; and Three councillors representing the Kawerau General Ward Note: the ward boundaries for both the Kawerau Māori Ward and the Kawerau General Ward align with the district's boundaries. 

  • Maintain eight councillors and the Mayor (supported by 75% of the respondents who gave feedback in the early engagement process) 

  • No community board (supported by 70% of respondents who gave feedback)  

Note: 

Feedback from the community conveyed that elected members and the Mayor can and do effectively represent the community without duplication of roles of a community board. Another reason was that the increased costs of adding a community board were not necessary as the councillors were already doing this job well.

Why has Kawerau District Council adopted the initial proposal? 

During the early engagement period From March to April 2024, 60% of the respondents wanted council to investigate the mixed system, with the belief that voters on both the Māori and general roll can have a greater say in electing councillors who would represent their interests in the district. 
Feedback from the community reflected that irrespective of individual views regarding Māori wards, the mixed system (combination model) offered open and transparent democracy with two ‘at large’ (district-wide) seats, while still providing for specific Māori representation. 
The decision to adopt the initial proposal was made on Wednesday, 17 July 2024 at an Extraordinary Meeting of Council and was unanimous. 

Who can I vote for with the initial proposal of the mixed 'combination model' system?

With the Mixed System (combination model): 

• A person on the Māori electoral roll will be able to vote for: 

o The Mayor 

o Candidates standing “at large” (or district-wide)

o Candidates standing for the Kawerau Māori ward   

• A person on the general electoral roll may vote for:  

o The Mayor  

o Canidates standing “at large” 

o Canidates standing for the Kawerau general ward  

In a ‘combination’ model for Māori, general and ‘at large’ (district wide) wards who can you vote for?

What is the other option for the district now that we have Māori and General wards?

In a wards model - based on retaining the Mayor and eight (8) councillors: 

A person on the Māori electoral roll can vote for:

  • The Mayor
  • Four candidates standing for the Kawerau Māori ward

A person on the general electoral roll can vote for:

  • The Mayor
  • Four candidates standing for the Kawerau General ward

In a ward model with Māori and General wards who can you vote for?

What is the process of the Representation Review? 

For the past year we have been talking to our community about the electoral process, with elected members voting to:   

(1) retain the First Past the Post (FPP) voting system on 6 September 2023   

(2) introduce Māori ward(s) on 22 November 2023

As Council voted to introduce Māori ward(s) in November 2023, in addition to general ward(s), we now need to consider how we best represent community voices at the council table with Māori ward(s) included. 

(3) The representation review is the third and final step of the process required before the 2025 elections that will be held on 11 October 2025.  

Do we have to make changes?  

Yes, the introduction of Māori ward(s) means we will have changes to the current representation. This means that there has been another 'ward' added to the district.    

Following the early engagement feedback, Council adopted the 'initial proposal' of how elected members will represent the district on Wednesday 17 July 2024. There is now the formal consultation and submission period from 22 July 2024 through to 26 August 2024.  

What decisions have been made? 

Our Council has already made two related decisions which are not part of this engagement process: 

  • The First Past the Post (FPP) electoral system is being retained for the 2025 elections. 
  • Māori ward councillors will be established for at least the 2025 elections  

Please note:  

The coalition government is progressing the Local Government (Electoral Legislation and Māori Wards and Māori Constituencies) Amendment Bill which will bring back the poll (or referendum) provisions for Māori wards so a poll is likely to be required with the 2025 local elections.

The outcome of the poll would apply for the 2028 and 2031 local elections. This may mean the Kawerau Māori ward may be in place for one term depending on the outcome of the 2025 poll; another representation review may then be required in 2027 (for 2028).

If Council choose to rescind their resolution to establish Māori wards once the Bill is passed (expected to be end of July 2024), this would impact on the current representation review and initial and final proposals, if already resolved.

Where can I give my feedback for this round of formal submissions? 

Via the Council website Online Survey 

Via Facebook.com/KawerauDistrictCouncil  

Hard copy surveys can be handed into the isite, library or Council offices 

Email submissions@kaweraudc.govt.nz  

Formal submissions run from Monday 22 July - Monday 26 August 2024

Will it be cheaper if we have less councillors? 

No, the pool of remuneration (cost) stays the same regardless of the number of councillors. The Remuneration Authority sets this budget for the district.  The only increase in costs would be if the community wanted a community board, this would be an additional (and unbudgeted) cost. 

Do we need to change the way our councillors are elected? 

Yes. The introduction of Māori ward(s) - means the district will have:  

  • Kawerau General ward seats elected by people on the general electoral roll 

  • Kawerau Māori ward seats elected by people on the Māori electoral roll  

  • There is also the option of having some councillors elected 'at large' by everyone  which is the system that the Council has adopted in the initial proposal. The reason for adopting this system, was that 60% of the respondents from the early engagement supported Council investigating this option. The reasoning stated was that it would enable all electors (voters) on the general roll and the Māori roll to have a greater say in electing councillors who would represent their interests in the district. Feedback stated that irrespective of individual views on the introduction of Māori ward(s) the mixed system offered open and transparent democracy with two 'at large' (district-wide) seats, while still providing for specific Māori representation with three Māori ward councillors at the table that would honour council's decision to introduce specific Māori representation.  

What is an elector?

An elector is someone who is eligible to vote. 

This means the person must be aged 18 or over on election day of 11 october 2025.

What is a candidate?

This is a person who is standing for election for a particular ward. These are the people or 'candidates' you can vote for in the next election. Under the initial proposal, people can stand for:

  • The Mayor 
  • An 'at large' district wide councillor
  • A general ward councillor
  • A Māori ward councillor

How do you become a candidate for election?

In mid-2025, there will be a call for people who wish to stand for council. 
A candidates’ meeting will be held to ensure that everyone who is considering putting their name forward for election understands what is required and what the role of a councillor or Mayor entails. 
The first step (in 2025) will be to complete an application form and have two people nominate you. The people who endorse your nomination, need to be on the same electoral roll as the ward you are standing for. 

What that means is: 
If you are standing for the Kawerau general ward seat – you will need two people to nominate you, who are listed on the general electoral roll. 
If you are standing for the Kawerau Māori ward seat – you will need two people to nominate you, who are listed on the Māori electoral roll. 
If you are standing for the two ‘at large’ seats – you will need two people to nominate you who are listed on either the Kawerau Māori electoral roll and/or the Kawerau general electoral roll. 

The people who nominate candidates, must reside in the area and that the candidate is standing for and must be on the same electoral roll that the person is standing for. 
The candidate, does not have to reside in the district, or be on the same electoral roll as they are standing for -  but both of their nominees must be on the same electoral roll that the candidate is standing for.

For more information on how to become a candidate

How many wards can a candidate stand for and who can vote for whom? 

A person standing for election in the 2025 local council elections for Kawerau can stand for only one ward, but they may choose to also stand for the Mayor, as follows: 

  •  Mayor 

(All voters can vote for the Mayor)
OR

  • Mayor, and ‘At Large’ Councillor 

(all voters, on the Māori electoral roll and the General electoral roll, can vote for the Mayor)
OR

  • Mayor, and, Kawerau General Ward councillor  

OR

  •  Mayor, and, Kawerau Māori Ward councillor 

OR

  •  ‘At Large’ Councillor 

(all voters, on the Māori electoral roll and the General electoral roll, can vote for ‘At Large’ candidates) 
OR

  •  Kawerau Māori Ward councillor 

(voters can only vote for these candidates if they are on the Māori electoral roll)
OR 

  •  Kawerau General Ward councillor 

(voters can only vote for these candidates if they are on the general electoral roll) 

What do you mean by having a combination of Māori ward, general ward and ‘at large’?  

In the Mixed 'combination model' system with six councillors elected from a Māori ward and a general ward, and two councillors elected 'at large' district wide. 

Everyone in the electoral population will vote for the Mayor and the 'at large' district wide councillors. If you are in the Māori electoral roll you will vote for three Māori ward councillors if you are in the general electoral roll you will vote for three general ward councillors.

In a ‘combination’ model for Māori, general and ‘at large’ (district wide) wards who can you vote for?

What is a community board? 

Community boards typically represent a smaller geographic area or ‘community of interest’ within their council/kaunihera, to ensure smaller communities’ voices aren’t lost in the big picture conversations | kōrero. 

There are now around 110 community boards in Aotearoa, ranging in size from those representing only a few hundred residents to more than 60,000 residents.   

Most members are elected during local body elections although council | kaunihera members can also be appointed to a community board. Note: this would entail an extra cost as currently Kawerau district does not have any community boards.  

70% of the people who gave feedback during the early engagement of the representation review, did not believe that Kawerau would benefit from having a community board or boards. The feedback stated that the current elected members, the eight councillors and the Mayor, already adequated represented the district and the people who reside here.  

Can things stay the same? 

No, with the introduction of a Kawerau Māori ward - Kawerau will have seats at the council table representing the Kawerau General Ward and the Kawerau Māori Ward.   

What is the basis for deciding how many Māori and General ward councillors there are? 

The Māori Electoral Population is currently 3,430 people or 43.86% of the total electoral population in the district. The General Electoral Population is currently 4,390 people or 56.14% of the total electoral population in the district. 

These statistics are used to determine the number of councillors representing Māori and general wards. For example, if we have a total of seven councillors, three will represent the Māori ward(s), and four will represent the general ward(s). 

Māori representation is being introduced based on the Local Electoral Act 2001 (LEA) legislative formula using Māori and general electoral populations (not electors):

nmm   =    mepd / (mepd + gepd) x nm

                        where -

nmm               is the number of Māori ward members

mepd              is the Māori electoral population or estimated Māori electoral population of the district (3,430)

gepd               is the general electoral population or estimated general electoral population of the district (4,390)

nm                  is the proposed number of total number members of the territorial authority (other than the Mayor)

Therefore, with the statistics above and the current arrangements (of a Mayor plus eight councillors), the calculation [nmm= 3,430/(3,430+4,390)*8] would provide for four Māori ward councillors and four general ward councillors [1]. 

The total electoral population is 7,820.

As of 2022, there were 5,215 electors (people eligible to vote) in the Kawerau District. This number is likely to increase for the 2025 elections as the population grows and people reach voting age.

[1] If the number of the Māori ward members (other than the mayor) calculated under subclause (1) includes a fraction, the fraction must be disregarded unless it exceeds a half. If the fraction exceeds a half, the number of Māori ward members must be the next whole number above the number that includes the fraction. Ref.LEA2001-Sch1A-2(3).

 

What is a ward?  

Generally wards are geographic areas of an area that an elected member represents (i.e., coastal ward in Ōpōtiki) that represent a specific area of interest (in this case it is a rural area of people who are living by coast). In an urban area, such as large cities, it could be a suburb etc within a city. 
Given Kawerau is small geographically, the community has not seen the need for wards on a geographic basis. 
However, now that there is Māori  representation the district will have General Wards and Māori wards. 

What is Māori ward(s)?  

A Māori ward is one way for Māori electoral roll voters, which are a defined community of interest, to be effectively represented under legislation. Instead of grouping electors by geographic location like other wards, all electors (voters) who are on the Māori electoral roll would vote in the Māori ward(s).  

Who can stand for election in a Māori ward? 

Anyone can stand for election in a Māori ward, but they cannot stand for both a general and a Māori ward at the same time. Candidates in Māori ward(s) do not have to be of Māori descent, but they need to be nominated by two people on the Māori electoral roll in the area they are standing. 

Who can stand for election in a general ward?  

Anyone can stand for election in a general ward, but they cannot stand for both a general and Māori ward at the same time. The person needs to be nominated by two people on the general electoral roll in the area they are standing. 

What is an ‘at large’ councillor?  

These councillors are elected by all voters within the district – in the same way that everyone can vote for the mayor. In Kawerau, we previously elected all our councillors ‘at large,’ but the introduction of Māori ward(s) means we will now have both Māori and general wards.  

It is possible to have a system that comprises a mixture of Māori and General ward councillors and ‘at large’ councillors. For instance, our mayor is already elected ‘at large’ by everyone, and these other ‘at large’ seats would also be elected by everyone on the electoral roll.  

Representation Review – Key Dates  

Preliminary consultation7 March – 5 April 2024
Council meeting to adopt initial proposal17 July 2024
Submission period on initial proposal     22 July – 26 August 2024  
Hearing/s for submitters to talk to Council11 September 2024
Deliberations on submissions and Council resolution for final proposal25 September 2024
Appeal/objection period30 September – 4 November 2024  
LGC determination (if required)  by 10 April 2025